Harry Shum Jr. got two perfect scores on Tuesday night — and still went home. The Dancing With the Stars semifinalist and his professional partner Jenna Johnson were eliminated at the end of the November 17 semifinals despite a flawless 60 out of 60 from the judges, the most shocking exit of Season 35 so far. By Wednesday morning, the question on everyone’s mind — who got eliminated on Dancing With the Stars — had surged past 200,000 searches on Google in the United States.
Shum and Johnson were, on the judges’ scorecards, the best dancers of the night. They opened with a Paso Doble to Rihanna’s “We Found Love” featuring Calvin Harris and earned a perfect 30 out of 30, with all three judges — Carrie Ann Inaba, Derek Hough and Bruno Tonioli — awarding 10s. Then they came back with a Quickstep to the Glee version of “Valerie” and did it again: another perfect 30. Two dances, two perfect scores, 60 out of 60 — and elimination anyway.
That is the cruel arithmetic of Dancing With the Stars. The judges’ scores are only half of the result. Viewer votes count for the rest, and the couple with the lowest combined total goes home — no matter what the judges thought. Shum and Johnson tied Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov at the top of the judges’ leaderboard, but the viewers did not rank them the same way. TV Insider’s analysis of the results suggests the night’s biggest vote-getter was the couple at the very bottom of the judges’ board.
That couple was Connor Wood and Rylee Arnold. Wood finished last with the judges, scoring 24 out of 30 on both of his dances for a total of 48 out of 60 — a full 12 points behind Shum and Johnson. But when hosts Julianne Hough and Alfonso Ribeiro read out the safe couples, Wood and Arnold were called first. They are through to the finale. Shum and Johnson are not.
The rest of the final five is now set. Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov, who also scored a perfect 60 out of 60, advance as the other favourites. Maura Higgins and Mark Ballas go through on 59 out of 60 — Higgins landed her first perfect score of the season with her samba. Ezra Frech and Daniella Karagach advance on 57, and Tatyana Ali and Jan Ravnik on 55. When the final two couples were left standing at the end of the night, it was Frech and Shum Jr. — and the name called was Shum’s.
The reaction was instant. Page Six called it a shocking semi-finals elimination, and fans online spent the night asking the same question: how does a couple with two perfect scores go home a week before the finale? The short answer is that this is how the show has always worked — the judges grade the dancing, America picks the winner, and the two do not always agree. The longer answer is that Shum, for all his polish, never built the voting base that a contestant like Wood brings into the ballroom every week.
Shum, best known as Mike Chang on Glee and now a star of Grey’s Anatomy, had been one of the season’s most consistent dancers. A week earlier, on Grammy Night, he and Johnson topped the leaderboard again with a salsa to Lady Gaga and Bruno Mars’ “Die With a Smile,” scoring 29 out of 30. That night, Jenna Dewan and Val Chmerkovskiy went home instead. This time, the perfect scores could not save him.
THE FULL SEMIFINAL LEADERBOARD
Here is how all six couples finished on the judges’ scorecards on Tuesday night. Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson: 60 out of 60. Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov: 60 out of 60. Maura Higgins and Mark Ballas: 59 out of 60. Ezra Frech and Daniella Karagach: 57 out of 60. Tatyana Ali and Jan Ravnik: 55 out of 60. Connor Wood and Rylee Arnold: 48 out of 60. The couple in first place and the couple in last place had opposite nights — and the couple in last place is the one dancing next week.
THE STORY SO FAR
Tuesday, November 10 — Grammy Night: Shum and Johnson top the leaderboard with their salsa to “Die With a Smile” (29 out of 30) and earn immunity from the dance-offs. Jenna Dewan and Val Chmerkovskiy are eliminated. Tuesday, November 17, 8 p.m. ET — the semifinals: the six remaining couples each dance twice, one ballroom routine and one Latin routine, for judges’ scores and viewer votes. Shum and Johnson earn two perfect 30s. Tuesday, November 17, around 10 p.m. ET — the results: Wood and Arnold are called safe first, followed by Glenn and Pashkov, Ali and Ravnik, and Higgins and Ballas. Shum and Johnson are eliminated. Wednesday, November 18 — “who got eliminated on dancing with the stars” passes 200,000 searches on Google Trends in the United States.
WHAT HAPPENS NEXT
The Season 35 finale airs on Tuesday, November 24, at 8 p.m. ET on ABC and Disney+, with the episode streaming the next day on Hulu. It is a three-hour episode, and for the first time in the show’s 20-plus year history it will air live nationwide on both coasts at the same time. The five remaining couples — Glenn and Pashkov, Higgins and Ballas, Frech and Karagach, Ali and Ravnik, and Wood and Arnold — will compete for the Len Goodman Mirrorball Trophy. Wood, the lowest scorer left in the competition, now looks like a genuine contender to win it outright: if he drew the most viewer votes on a night when he finished last with the judges, the finale is his to lose.




